Payments in Marketplaces: A Comprehensive Guide

Updated 24 April 2025

1. Introduction

Purpose of the Article

The rise of online marketplaces has fundamentally reshaped how goods and services are exchanged in the digital age. From e-commerce giants to niche vertical marketplaces, the ecosystem continues to evolve rapidly. 

However, one component remains universally critical across all marketplace models— payments. This Payments in Marketplaces guide aims to provide a comprehensive, expert-level understanding of payments in online marketplaces. 

Whether you’re a developer, entrepreneur, business analyst, or platform owner, this resource will help you navigate the complexities of marketplace payment flows, compliance, and technology. 

Drawing from real-world practices, regulatory frameworks, and platform architectures, this guide serves as both a foundational and advanced resource.  

Importance of Understanding Marketplace Payments

Payments are the lifeblood of any marketplace. A well-structured payment system not only ensures smooth transactions but also builds trust between buyers and sellers, facilitates compliance with financial regulations, and supports sustainable revenue generation. 

In an environment where customer expectations for seamless experiences are higher than ever, platforms need to offer secure, transparent, and efficient payment processes. This becomes even more crucial as marketplaces scale globally, deal with cross-border transactions, and manage multi-party payments. 

This article will walk you through the essential components of marketplace payments—covering everything from business models to compliance requirements—equipping you with the knowledge to build or refine a robust payment infrastructure.  

2. What is a Marketplace?

Definition and Key Characteristics

An online marketplace is a digital platform that connects multiple buyers and sellers, facilitating the exchange of goods or services. Unlike traditional eCommerce stores, where a single vendor sells directly to customers, marketplaces allow third-party vendors to list and sell their offerings through a shared infrastructure.  

marketplaces

Key characteristics of a marketplace include:

Evolution of Online Marketplaces

The marketplace model has evolved significantly over the past two decades. Starting with eBay’s pioneering peer-to-peer auctions in the 1990s, the online marketplace concept has evolved considerably. 

Today, major platforms like Amazon, Alibaba, and Etsy dominate, facilitating a wide range of business and consumer interactions, including B2C, B2B, C2C, and P2P models.  

According to Statista, global marketplace sales accounted for over $3.25 trillion USD in 2023, representing more than 67% of global eCommerce transactions

This growth is fueled by increased internet access, mobile adoption, and changing consumer behavior towards platform-based purchasing (Statista, 2024).  

Modern marketplaces have diversified into sectors such as:

“A marketplace platform is not just a catalog of vendors—it’s an ecosystem that thrives on seamless interactions, robust backend systems, and frictionless payments.”

3. Marketplace Business and Revenue Models

Understanding the business and revenue models behind marketplaces is crucial for building a sustainable and profitable platform. Each model affects how payments are handled, how vendors are onboarded, and how trust is maintained between all parties.  

marketplace-business-and-revenue-models

3.1 Commission-Based Model

The commission-based model is the most common in marketplace ecosystems. Here, the platform charges a percentage of each transaction made through the site. This model aligns with performance and scales easily as the number of transactions grows. 

Example: Amazon, Airbnb, and Etsy charge commissions on every sale made by vendors or hosts. 

According to a report by Juniper Research, global platform commission revenue is expected to exceed $500 billion by 2025, driven largely by marketplaces (Juniper Research, 2023).  

3.2 Subscription or Membership-Based Model

In this model, sellers or buyers (or both) pay a recurring fee to access the platform or premium features. It ensures consistent revenue regardless of transaction volume. 

Example: LinkedIn Premium for service providers or Amazon’s Seller Central Professional plan. This model works well in B2B or niche service marketplaces, where access to a curated audience or specialized tools justifies the subscription cost.  

3.3 Listing Fee Model

Marketplaces may charge a fee to list products or services, regardless of whether a transaction takes place. This model is often used by platforms with high visibility or specialized audiences. 

Example: Etsy charges a nominal listing fee per item, which is separate from its transaction commission. This model can be combined with commissions to offset platform operating costs, especially in lower-volume niches.  

3.4 Freemium Model

The freemium model offers basic services for free while charging for advanced features like better listing visibility, analytics, or priority support. 

Example: Fiverr offers basic listings for free but provides premium seller services through subscriptions like “Seller Plus.” This model encourages onboarding of new vendors while allowing the platform to monetize power users.  

3.5 Lead Fee Model

Instead of charging for transactions, the platform earns by charging vendors for access to potential leads. This is common in services marketplaces where deals are closed off-platform. Example: Thumbtack and Bark charge professionals for each lead or inquiry they receive.  

3.6 Hybrid Revenue Models

Many modern marketplaces adopt a hybrid model, combining commissions, subscriptions, listing fees, and freemium features. This creates multiple revenue streams and provides flexibility across different types of sellers. 

Example: Alibaba uses a combination of membership plans (for supplier visibility), advertising, and transaction-based fees for different segments.  

4. Role of Payments in a Marketplace

Why Payments Are Core to Marketplace Success

Payments are not just a backend function—they are the strategic backbone of a marketplace. A seamless, secure, and well-integrated payment system directly impacts user experience, platform trust, vendor satisfaction, and overall business viability. 

A McKinsey report on global payments highlighted that digital payments accounted for 72% of all global eCommerce transactions, underscoring the critical role of robust payment infrastructure in digital commerce.  

Marketplaces that neglect payment optimization often face:

Conversely, platforms with frictionless payment systems build long-term user retention and strong revenue flows.  

Payment Experience and User Trust

Trust is a currency in marketplaces—and payment experiences often determine how trustworthy a platform feels. Users expect:  

A survey by Baymard Institute found that 18% of users abandon carts due to a “too long/complicated checkout process,” while 17% cite concerns over payment security (Baymard, 2024). Integrating intuitive, mobile-friendly, and secure payment workflows is vital for trust and conversion rates—especially in cross-border or high-value transactions.  

Revenue Collection and Distribution

For marketplace operators, payment infrastructure isn’t just about collecting money—it’s also about disbursing it fairly and compliantly. This includes:  

Ensuring the right logic is applied at every touchpoint—from checkout to payout—helps streamline accounting, avoid manual errors, and maintain vendor trust.  

“Payments are not just a feature in a marketplace—they are the infrastructure on which user confidence and operational integrity are built.”  

5. Types of Marketplaces and Their Payment Flows

Marketplace payment needs can vary significantly based on the business model. Whether it’s a peer-to-peer exchange or a complex B2B transaction, each type of marketplace requires a tailored payment flow to ensure compliance, trust, and efficiency.  

types-of-marketplaces-and-their-payment-flows

5.1 Consumer-to-Consumer (C2C)

 

5.2 Business-to-Consumer (B2C)

5.3 Business-to-Business (B2B)

5.4 Peer-to-Peer (P2P)

6. Marketplace Payment Flows and Structures

The structure of payments in a marketplace is not just about collecting money—it governs how funds are split, when they are disbursed, and how stakeholders interact financially. A well-defined flow ensures compliance, transparency, and operational efficiency.  

marketplace-payments-flows-and-structures

6.1 Real-Time Split Payments

Real-time split payments automatically divide the payment among the seller, the platform (for commission), and any third parties at the time of transaction. This eliminates the need for manual settlements and improves cash flow for vendors. Example: Stripe Connect, Adyen MarketPay. Benefits:  

6.2 Delayed/On-Hold Payments (Escrow Model)

The escrow model holds funds after purchase until a condition is met (e.g., delivery confirmation). This is common in service-based and high-risk product marketplaces. Example: Airbnb (release after stay), Upwork (milestone-based). Benefits:  

6.3 Aggregated Payments and Payouts

In this model, the platform collects payments from multiple buyers and pays out to sellers in bulk, either periodically or upon request. Use Case: Marketplaces with many microtransactions or subscription-style purchases (e.g., Patreon, Gumroad). Advantages:  

6.4 Multi-party Payment Distribution Models

Some marketplaces involve more than just buyers and sellers—think affiliates, logistics providers, or software partners. Payments must be split across these parties with traceable, rule-based automation. Example: Amazon (involving sellers, shippers, and affiliate marketers). Key Considerations:  

6.5 Refunds, Disputes, and Chargebacks

No payment system is complete without a process for handling refunds, disputes, and chargebacks. These elements directly impact platform credibility and financial health. Best Practices:  

Marketplace operators must carefully choose their payment structure based on the nature of their ecosystem, target audience, regulatory obligations, and technical capabilities. A misaligned flow can result in financial loss, legal exposure, and reputational damage.  

7. Payment Regulations for Marketplaces

Navigating the regulatory landscape is one of the most challenging aspects of building and scaling a marketplace. Since marketplaces often facilitate financial transactions on behalf of third parties (sellers or service providers), they may fall under financial regulation depending on the jurisdiction and payment model. Failing to comply can result in hefty fines, legal action, and platform bans. Here are the key regulatory domains that marketplace operators need to understand.  

payment-regulations-for-marketplaces

7.1 KYC (Know Your Customer)

KYC regulations require platforms to verify the identity of sellers (and in some cases buyers) to prevent fraud, money laundering, and terrorism financing. Key KYC steps:  

7.2 AML (Anti-Money Laundering)

AML frameworks are designed to detect and report suspicious transactions. Marketplaces must:  

7.3 PCI DSS Compliance

Any platform handling credit or debit card information must comply with PCI DSS (Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard). This includes:  

7.4 PSD2 and SCA (for EU)

PSD2 (Payment Services Directive 2) is a European regulation that governs electronic payments. A critical component is Strong Customer Authentication (SCA), which mandates multi-factor authentication for most online transactions. Marketplace Impact:  

7.5 Licensing and Registration as a Payment Facilitator or Institution

Depending on the flow of funds, a marketplace may be required to register as:

7.6 Handling Buyer and Seller Identity Verification

Regulatory compliance also demands the ability to:

7.7 Role of Third-Party Payment Processors in Compliance

To reduce regulatory burden, many marketplaces partner with regulated payment providers (e.g., Stripe Connect, Adyen, PayPal for Marketplaces). These processors offer:  

Marketplace founders and operators must treat payments and compliance as core strategic priorities, not afterthoughts. Regulatory expectations are increasing globally, and marketplaces that proactively implement frameworks for identity, security, and transparency are best positioned for long-term trust and growth.  

8. Security in Marketplace Payments

Security is not just a technical requirement in marketplace payments—it’s a fundamental pillar of user trust. With increasing sophistication in fraud tactics and growing consumer expectations for safety, marketplaces must prioritize payment security from day one.  

Why Payment Security Matters

A single data breach or fraudulent transaction can result in:

Common Threats to Payment Security

Security Best Practices for Marketplaces

To protect buyers, sellers, and the platform itself, marketplaces should adopt a multi-layered approach to payment security:

Leveraging Secure Payment Providers

Partnering with reputable PCI DSS Level 1-compliant gateways like Stripe, PayPal, or Adyen can offload much of the security infrastructure. These providers:  

“Security is not just a feature—it is the foundation of trust that marketplaces are built upon.” — World Economic Forum, Digital Trust Framework (2022)  

As fraudsters evolve, so must marketplaces. Investing in security upfront is far more cost-effective than reacting to breaches or chargebacks after damage is done. User safety and data integrity should be treated as competitive advantages, not just obligations.  

9. Marketplace Payment Providers and Gateways

A well-chosen payment provider is the backbone of a successful marketplace. Beyond enabling transactions, payment gateways offer critical services like KYC compliance, fraud prevention, currency conversion, tax handling, and even dispute resolution. For marketplaces, the challenge isn’t just accepting payments—it’s managing a complex network of pay-ins, pay-outs, and payment splits across multiple stakeholders, often in multiple countries.  

Key Capabilities to Look for

When choosing a payment provider, marketplace operators should look for features such as:

Leading Payment Providers for Marketplaces

Here are some of the most popular and capable providers supporting complex marketplace payment workflows:  

  1. Stripe Connect: One of the most developer-friendly options, supporting real-time split payments, automated seller onboarding, and extensive global compliance coverage. Used by platforms like Kickstarter, Shopify, and Instacart.  
  2. PayPal for Marketplaces: Allows handling parallel/chained payments, seller onboarding via PayPal accounts, and offers PayPal Credit/Buyer Protection. Trusted by Upwork and eBay.  
  3. Adyen MarketPay: Built for larger international marketplaces, offering advanced risk/compliance tools, multi-party splits, and unified commerce. Used by Booking.com, Etsy, and GOAT.  
  4. MangoPay: Tailored for marketplaces/crowdfunding, offering escrow, multi-currency wallets, and full KYC/AML support. Popular in Europe (Vinted, KissKissBankBank).  
  5. Checkout.com: A newer player with strong support for modular API-first workflows, ML-powered fraud prevention, and global payment methods.  

When to Use Custom vs. Pre-Built Gateways

Situation Use a Pre-Built Gateway Build Custom Solution
Startups with limited engineering ✅ Yes ❌ No
Need for global regulatory coverage ✅ Yes ❌ No
Highly unique commission logic ⚠ Maybe ✅ Yes (if well-resourced)
Operating in high-risk verticals ✅ (with risk-focused gateway) ✅ Yes (with in-house controls)

Export to Sheets

How Bagisto Supports Payment Integration

Although Bagisto has been mentioned earlier, it’s worth noting that it supports a wide range of third-party payment gateways, including Stripe, PayPal, Razorpay, and others. Its extensible architecture enables marketplace owners to add custom payment logic, making it suitable for diverse regional and business-specific needs. This flexibility is particularly useful for startups and SMEs building localized or niche marketplaces that require integration with local payment gateways or alternative payment methods (APMs).  

Selecting the right payment provider is not just a technical decision—it’s a strategic move that affects seller onboarding, user trust, regulatory compliance, and ultimately, platform scalability.  

10. Key Challenges and Considerations in Marketplace Payments

While payments can be a powerful growth enabler, managing them in a marketplace ecosystem introduces a unique set of challenges that traditional eCommerce does not face. These complexities stem from the multi-party nature of transactions, cross-border operations, regulatory burdens, and diverse buyer-seller expectations.  

key-challenges-and-considerations

  1. Managing Split Payments and Commissions: Marketplaces often need to split a single payment between multiple parties. Without automation, this can become a compliance and operational nightmare. Many platforms use Stripe Connect, Adyen, or MangoPay to automate this.  
  2. Ensuring Global Compliance: Expanding marketplaces face varying regulatory obligations like local taxes (VAT/GST), KYC/AML, and licensing (EMI/MSB).  
  3. Handling Refunds, Disputes, and Chargebacks: This is especially difficult in C2C/P2P models where the platform may bear liability. Challenges include chargeback abuse and ambiguous policies. Clear policies and automated tools are essential.  
  4. Delayed Payouts and Seller Trust: Holding funds protects buyers but delayed payouts can erode seller trust. Balancing buyer protection and seller friction is key, often managed via escrow or milestone payments.  
  5. Fraud Detection and Risk Management: Marketplaces must actively monitor for fraud using tools that analyze payment velocity, device fingerprinting, and user behavior. Tools like Sift, Signifyd, and Riskified use AI for real-time prevention.  
  6. High Payment Failure Rates in Emerging Markets: Low card penetration requires supporting Alternative Payment Methods (APMs) like UPI, M-Pesa, or BNPL options. Choose gateways with localized options.  
  7. Taxation and Withholding Requirements: Marketplaces may need to withhold taxes, report earnings (e.g., 1099-K), and register for VAT globally.  
  8. User Experience vs. Compliance: Strict compliance (complex KYC/SCA) can hurt user experience and lead to abandonment. Use progressive verification for a smoother flow.  

Marketplace payments sit at the intersection of technology, regulation, finance, and experience. Solving these challenges requires payment infrastructure that is scalable, secure, compliant, and user-first. Platforms achieving this gain loyalty and credibility.

11. Future Trends in Marketplace Payments

The world of marketplace payments is evolving rapidly. Staying ahead of technological, behavioral, and regulatory shifts is critical for competitiveness, scalability, and compliance.  

  1. Embedded Finance and Banking-as-a-Service (BaaS): Marketplaces are becoming financial platforms, offering branded cards, wallets, early payouts, and working capital loans.  Example: Amazon Lending, Shopify Capital (issued >$5B by 2023).  
  2. Rise of Alternative Payment Methods (APMs): Beyond cards, users prefer digital wallets (50% of global eCommerce payments), BNPL (>$450B volume by 2026), QR codes, and crypto. Integrating APMs boosts conversion and regional reach. (Source: Worldpay 2024 Report).  
  3. AI-Powered Fraud Prevention: Next-gen AI tools flag anomalies, detect synthetic identities, and assess risk in real-time. Providers like Sardine, Persona, and Sift lead in AI-first fraud management for platforms.  
  4. Faster Payouts via Real-Time Rails: Sellers expect instant access to funds via systems like FedNow (USA), SEPA Instant (EU), UPI (India). Payout windows are shifting from days to seconds. “Instant payouts are not a feature anymore—they’re an expectation.” — PYMNTS.com, 2024.  
  5. Decentralized and Tokenized Payments: Blockchain solutions (e.g., stablecoins like USDC) are explored for lower cross-border fees, smart contract escrow, and digital ID verification, especially in NFT/freelance markets.  
  6. RegTech Integration for Real-Time Compliance: Marketplaces use Regulatory Technology (RegTech) to automate eKYC, AML screening, and tax reporting. Tools like ComplyAdvantage, Jumio, TaxJar make compliance scalable.  
  7. Platform-Owned Payment Infrastructure: Mature marketplaces may build in-house payment solutions for cost savings and control. 🛠 Example: Etsy acquired Adyen to build its stack.  
  8. Sustainable and Ethical Payments: Growing ESG focus leads to carbon-offset payments, donation prompts, and transparent payout policies, attracting ethically minded consumers.  

The future of payments is about speed, security, ownership, inclusivity, transparency, and adaptive intelligence. Embracing these shifts builds resilient, scalable, and user-centric ecosystems.  

12. Conclusion

Marketplace payments are the financial and trust engine powering the platform. Ensuring seamless interactions, navigating regulations, and enabling fast payouts is foundational and strategic.  

This guide covered:

Success depends on the robustness, transparency, and efficiency of your financial infrastructure.  

Final Word: Choosing the Right Foundation

Whether building a niche marketplace or scaling globally, your payment infrastructure must align with your vision. Bagisto, an open-source Laravel-based eCommerce framework, provides the flexibility to integrate with popular payment providers and customize workflows. Its modular structure suits businesses aiming for speed-to-market and scalability.  

Investing in the right tools and strategies turns complex payments into a competitive advantage—fostering trust, driving revenue, and delivering exceptional user experience

. . .

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked*


Be the first to comment.

Start a Project




    Message Sent!

    If you have more details or questions, you can reply to the received confirmation email.

    Back to Home